Merit Protection Commissioner
We contribute to safe, effective and harmonious public sector workplaces through our review, complaint and inquiry functions






Review of performance decisions
[0:01]
If you’re an APS or Parliamentary Service employee, and have been through a performance process that you think is wrong, unfair, or unreasonable...
[0:09]
…you have the right to review performance management decisions that affect you- by the Merit Protection Commissioner.
[0:16]
We review things like:
- a poor or unsatisfactory performance rating
- a decision to implement a performance improvement plan or a ‘managing underperformance process’
- any action taken as a result of an unsatisfactory performance management process (excluding a decision to terminate your employment)
[0:35]
You will need to seek a review with your agency first to resolve the issue.
[0:40]
If you are not satisfied with the outcome, you have 60 days to tell your agency that you would like a secondary review by the MPC, and they must send your matter to us. Your agency will provide us with the information relevant to the decision.
[0:56]
We will conduct a full merits review, and may look at:
- your point of view
- your manager’s point of view
- your job description
- performance expectations
- work samples
- whether performance discussions have taken place between you and your manager
- and if you were provided with constructive feedback so that you were not surprised by the decision.
[1:20]
We then notify you, and your agency- our recommendation to ‘uphold’ their decision as fair, or whether we have found the decision to be unfair, and should be ‘varied’ or ‘set aside’.
[1:33]
The agency should then reconsider their decision or make a different decision.
[1:40]
In addition to performance management decisions, the MPC can also review other workplace decisions that affect you for free, and independently.
[1:49]
Find out more on our website, or contact one of our team members.
[MPC contact details appear: mpc.gov.au, (02) 8239 5330, review@mpc.gov.au]
[1:53]
The Merit Protection Commissioner: supporting integrity and accountability in the public and Parliamentary Service
[MPC brand mark appears].
[1:59]
[MPC Government Crest appears].
[1:59 -2:03]
[Music plays out].
Review of code matters
[0:01]
Are you an APS or Parliamentary Service employee who is subject to a Code of Conduct process?
[0:07]
Are you worried that a decision is wrong, unfair or unreasonable?
[0:12]
If so, you are able to seek review by the Merit Protection Commissioner.
[0:16]
The MPC can review any finding that you have breached the Code of Conduct or a decision to impose a sanction of a
[0:24]
reduction in classification, reassignment of duties, reduction in salary, deduction from salary by way of fine, reprimand.
[0:34]
The MPC cannot review a decision to terminate your employment.
[0:39]
For that, you need to apply to the Fair Work Commission.
[0:43]
There are many reasons why an agency will investigate an employee.
[0:48]
Common allegations are that an employee has made an unauthorised access of client databases,
[0:54]
not recorded their attendance correctly, bullied or harassed another person,
[1:00]
failed to follow directions or agency procedures, failed to perform their duties with care and diligence.
[1:07]
For a breach or sanction decision, you can make an application directly to the MPC
[1:14]
for a first and final review without going through your agency. Time limits apply.
[1:20]
The breach and sanction are two separate decisions.
[1:24]
So don't wait until the sanction decision is made to apply for a review of the breach decision.
[1:30]
You have 60 days from each decision to apply to us for review.
[1:35]
When we review a breach decision, we look first at the process, for example
[1:40]
were your agency's procedures followed and were you given procedural fairness?
[1:45]
We then consider the evidence the agency has gathered in its investigation and whether you actually did what was alleged.
[1:52]
Finally, we decide whether your actions were a breach of the Code of Conduct.
[1:58]
When it comes to reviewing a sanction decision, we consider whether the sanction imposed on you is fair and proportionate.
[2:05]
Once we have completed our review, we will notify you and your agency of our recommendation
[2:12]
to either uphold the breach finding, or sanction decision, or whether it should be varied or set aside.
[2:21]
Other code of conduct related decisions, such as a suspension decision or the decision to start
[2:26]
an investigation, must be reviewed first by your agency.
[2:33]
If you are not happy with your agency's decision, you can then seek a review by the MPC.
[2:39]
In addition to Code of Conduct decisions, the MPC can also review other workplace decisions that affect you.
[2:47]
If you would like more information about your review rights and how to apply, visit our website or contact one of our team members.
[2:55]
The Merit Protection Commissioner. Supporting integrity and accountability in the Public and Parliamentary Service.